I thought it was a boring Chinese brick
On paper, Dream of the Red Chamber (红楼梦) looks like punishment: 120 chapters, 400+ characters. It's a drama about rich kids and spoiled neurotic princesses.
Yet, it was considered a Classical Chinese literature, among the four great novels:
- Three Kingdoms (三国演义)
- Journey to the West (西游记)
- Outlaws of the Marsh (水浒传)
- Dream of the Red Chamber (红楼梦)
Of all books I could choose to read, the Dream of the Red Chamber was the one that I was most hesitant to read. I hated the cultural pressure to read it, mentally checking out and went through life thinking I wasn't missing out anything great.
It's not like I haven't gave it a try -- my first exposure was during primary school when it was forced to me as a curricular.
It is full of cryptic poems and characters that are hard to remember. I rather read about mythified heroes like Sun Wukong, Guan Yu, Zhu GeLiang, than some no name princesses who are obsessed with poetry and crying all the time.
When I finally pushed through, it turned my own life into one of its sermons. I stopped reading about the Jia clan and started seeing my own money/status grind, my envy, my blackpill loops as just another simulation through the same garden.
It took me decades to discover the "Matrix" (what we modernly refer to as the "fake material world"), and this novel just exposes it all in a week session of reading.
The novel's insight (Spoilers)
The Red Chamber represents the endless parties, romances, gossip, debts, affairs, and the aristocratic collapse are the Buddhist/Taoist/Confucian gospel in action.
The profoundness is not in "reading about a novel where rich kids party until they die," rather it's "watch these rich kids party until they die and then realize it was all empty."
Why this novel hits harder than expected
Many novels, religious scripts, and scrolls or ancient morality only show you one perspective of the world. They will tell you that materialism is the root of all evil, you should be detached from it, and seek enlightenment and God.
To many common people, it just sounds like cope for the losers or weak who cannot win the material game.
"Everything is empty at the top" -- Person at the top
This sounds irresponsible and pretentious to those who weren't at the top or who are still actively trying to climb. It is especially more relevant when the messenger's material success is perceived to come from good luck or winning the genetic lottery.
The Dream of Red Chamber (abbreviated as HLM) is the first novel that shows you the other side of the story.
Greentext synopsis
The entire 800,000‑word epic is the cautionary tale the stone *lives througstay sensitive to all material attachment
Characters' Analysis
Jia Baoyu
He is the guy you wish you were instead of being a wage cuck. He wins the genetic lottery, never needs to work a day in his life, and gets to live in a beautiful garden with beautiful girls.
- Starts as a rock. Ends as a monk.
- Isekai'd into the Jia clan as the most simped after rich kid.
- Falls in love with Lin Daiyu, the most beautiful girl in the garden.
- Gets tricked into marrying the "perfect" girl (Baochai) by scheming old ladies.
- Family gets raided by the government, loses everything.
- Waifu Daiyu dies from pure emotional damage caused by her sensitivity to real world and insecurity of her ability
- Has a total breakdown, then finally wake up.
Lin Daiyu
She is the OG neurotic doomer waifu from 18th century.
- Fragile health
- Sensitive emotions
- Writes 10/10 sad‑girl poetry at 3 a.m.
- Overthinks every micro‑interaction with her situationship
- Burns her entire life's work when it inevitably crastay sensitive to all material attachmentONAL DAMAGE
Every iconic poem of hers is basically her internal monologue of profound sadness and meta-introspection:
- "Spring will end, flowers fall, I'll die and nobody will bury me"
- "Even the cleanest jade gets marked by worry"
- "Why bloom if the garden is already scheduled to wither in autumn?"
Annoying, sensitive, self-conscious prick. But she is more than just a drama‑queen LARP. She is also someone who sees the full Buddhist blackpill (everything is empty form) while still being forced to play the Confucian game (stay in the mansion, be the perfect delicate cousin, simp for the jade boy, keep the family face).
Daiyu is you if you are a foid with tweeting skills and zero coping mechanisms.
Xue Baochai
She is the S-tier trad waifu you can have in the Confucian meta.
- Smart, pretty, resourceful, and capable
- A woman who actually speaks logic, responsibility, and accountability
- Simp for the jade boy (even after knowing he is still in love with his dead waifu)
- Not selfish and actually keep the family face by sacrificing her own happiness
- Politics 100
- Can actually say profound shit to console her husband when he is depressed instead of being a drama
- A woman who ACTUALLY speaks logic, responsibility, and accountability!
Character Rankings
S-tier
Xue Baochai
My favourite character. Came from a tough place, suck up to many injustices, and still puts many things above her.
With her intellect and beauty, she has many opportunities to climb the material ladder. Yet, she "throws" it all to her devotion to some man and her family.
You love watching her being a pleasant person in general, always smiling and helping other people, while also being sensitive enough to mediate other people's conflict and emotional volatility. You feel frustrated when you see how much she is repressing to keep everyone in good terms with each other.
It is not easy to get a woman that is smart, sensitive, capable, logical, accountable, emotionally stable, loyal, and moral. 1 Perhaps that's why she appeal so much to male audiences.
Wang Xifeng
Baoyu's sister in law (brother's wife). Most wiki would just declare her as a villain, antagonist, an unpleasant bitch. They will complain about how she is selfish, greedy, manipulative, and a political sucker.
But when inspecting the story, you learn that villains are not obvious. She does many moral and good things other people are unwilling to do, and often covered multiple niches unique to her.
Example:
- visiting Qin Keqing's when she is sick and dying
- very accomodating to old people
- very sensitive to family's emotions and needs
- great at managing and disciplining a large groups of peasants and workers
- very good at making jokes and keeping guests entertained, and also knowing how to draw the line between being funny and being offensive
She doesn't play by the rules, thats why its easy to see her as a villain. Yes, there were many times she didn't operate with good intentions, and sometimes even with malicious intent, but 95% of the time she is the person you rather be around than any other character in practical life.
The point is real villains are complicated. They don't just declare themselves as villains and do evil all day. Often we choose to keep them around because of how useful they have been in regular parts of life.
Her usury scheme was not considered moral by the audience, but she generated so much profits for the family to afford the lavish lifestyle for so many people for many years and many just enjoyed the fruits of her "corruption" thanklessly.
A-tier
Xiren
Headmaid of Jia Baoyu.
Practically, she is Xue Baochai 2.0. She is dutiful, sensitive, and capable. The only difference is she isn't as smart, witty, and socially favored by people around that time. You will feel bad for her for being born in the wrong time.
In modern times, she would have been a 8/10-9/10 girl people line up for, instead of being an invisible servant who cleans up all the mess created by the rich kids and occasionally gets unfairly punished for it.
F-tier
Too many to count. So many characters just don't matter and died in early chapters or get off-screened.
The few things you usually learn from these characters are:
- never goon
- dont be unlucky
- dont be born poor
- dont be emotional and violent
- never goon
Best written character
Lin Daiyu.
For a long time, I misunderstood Lin Daiyu as just an annoying, sad, poetic girl who cries all day.
Practically, it would be annoying to meet such a person in real life, but fictionally she is capable of teaching the most lessons to the audience.
To start out, she is a walking paradox of extreme sensitivity + self‑awareness + and karmic self‑sabotage.
Her complexity comes from being the only person in the Material Garden who fully sees the trap yet cannot stop walking into it.
Layer 1: Surface & symbolism (The Fairy Flower)
Orphaned early (mother dead, father dies later), LDY is raised in the Jia mansion as a guest.
In the heavenly frame story, she is the Crimson Pearl Flower who watered the Divine Stone (Baoyu) with dew for 1,600+ years. This means she now repaying the “debt of tears” in human form. Every tear she sheds is karmically pre‑loaded. The novel keeps reminding us she is literally crying her lifespan away in this new reincarnation.
Layer 2: Psychological realism (Trauma + sensitivity)
With chronic illness (coughing blood, weak lungs) + emotional fragility, LDY has a constant fear of abandonment.
In ancient China context, women are not strong enough and culturally allowed to be independent and have agency, they are forced to rely on their husbands for survival, and hence playing the Material Game is the only way to survive.
That said, she annoyingly weaponizes her own vulnerability by being a sharp tongue, envious, passive‑aggressive poet. This is unlike XBC who is equally as smart, but often leans to humbling herself to make other people feel less insecure.
The interpretation of her "dramatic" behavior is that she is just an insecure girl who is terrified that if she isn't perfect or constantly proven loved, she will be discarstay sensitive to all material attachment emotional intelligence is peak for being able to read every micro‑expression, every political marriage hint, and every family scheme. She knows Baochai is the "safe" match long before the forced wedding plot.
She craves love more than anyone, yet her pride and fear make her push Baoyu away constantly. She is an anxious‑avoidant attached teenager that takes herself too seriously.
Layer 3: Philosophical blackpill
LDY is the few major character who understands the "Matrix" while still living inside the dream.
Her poems (Burial of Flowers, Autumn Window Wind & Rain, Peach Blossom) are more than just pretty sadness. They statements of consciousness to the metaphysical reality:
- "Flowers fall, person dies, both unknown" = explicit impermanence.
- "Pure they came, pure they return, better than sinking in the gutter" = her quiet vow to die before she becomes a Post-wall Stacyhag.
She sees the entire material garden as an illusion, yet still chooses to feel every petal and every slight with 1000% intensity.
Unlike Baoyu (who eventually logs off the Matrix) or Baochai (who plays the ranked game detached), Daiyu refuses both easy paths. She stays fully attached and fully awake, then meets her end with agony and tragedy.
Layer 4: Plot liquidity & influence
LDY barely speaks in long monologues, yet almost every major turning point revolves around her:
- Her jealousy poems trigger the love‑triangle misunderstandings.
- Her burning of the poems is the emotional climax of the entire 120 chapters.
- Her death (hearing the wedding music while coughing blood) is the exact moment the material garden paradise officially dies.
- Her annoying and sarcastic behavior triggers most of the family's drama and conflicts.
TL;DR Daiyu
Daiyu is an orphan poet who knows the simulation is fake, knows she's here to repay a karmic debt, knows attachment will destroy her, and still chooses to stay sensitive to all material attachment until her body dissolves from crying (puked blood and died during the wedding between Baoyu and Baochai).
That combination of cosmic awareness + human heartbreak + self‑destructive pride is why she is the perfect character to mirror the audience's own inner contradictions and self-sabotage.
Why this novel is actually worth your time
In modern times, its better to just watch the 50-episode show. The novel is very hard to read and understand. That said, the literature is great cecause it does what no other book before or since has pulled off at this level:
Three‑religion synthesis in one family story
It combines the values of Confucianism (make money, honor ancestors, climb status), Buddhism (impermanence, debt of tears, final awakening), and Taoism (natural stone, garden as fleeting paradise, "everything returns to void").
It doesn't lecture or preach like a Bible on how futile materialism is, but it shows the tension in 400+ living, breathing characters in the Qing dynasty pursuing the 3 contradicting values and let you decide for yourself.
Encyclopedia of human experience disguised as drama and mundane slice of life
It shows the rise and fall of a real aristocratic clan (Cao Xueqin, our author's own family got raided IRL).
You feel the garden parties as peak civilization, the genetic lottery as something you missed out, the love triangle as soul‑crushing (even when it hints the collapse as inevitable from the start).
Then you watch the characters you grew attached to meeting fates you can relate in your own life, sometimes happy, sometimes repressed, sometimes tragic.
Then, the monk says "I told you so" right at the end and it recontextualizes everything you have read and lived so far.
The three routes of Real Life: Daiyu, Baochai, Baoyu
When you zoom out, the Red Chamber quietly hands you three archetypal "builds" for playing life in the material world:
- Daiyu route: maximum sensitivity, maximum attachment. Feel everything, write the best poems, refuse to compromise truth and die young, consumed by your own emotions.
- Baochai route: maximum discipline, minimum visible attachment. Play the Confucian game flawlessly, secure money/status/marriage, keep the clan afloat as long as possible, but accept some inner hollowness as the price of survival.
- Baoyu route: uninstall. Play the game fully, love hard, suffer harder, then log off and walk into the snow with the monks.
Unlike religious gospels that tell you to pick the void, or business marketing books that tell you to pick the material world, the novel shows you the consequences of both.
Reading it as an adult, I realized I have been accidentally running a modern Daiyu build: hyper‑aware, hyper‑online, overly sensitive to the decline I am seeing from the West and East Asian civilization.
There were times when I noticed I was hesitating my own ambitions because "the game is fake anyway."
It makes a cute story for a 17yo LARPing girl in a novel. It makes the monks who preached the values of embracing the void happy. It is lethal at 35 when you still broke, when enemies are at your borders, when your government and democratic civillians do not respect you enough to get anything done according to your will.
How it actually changed my outlook on money, status, and work
Sorry if this is going to sound like a LinkedIn slop poast, but it really mattered. I stopped reading Red Chamber as literature and started using it as a decision framework.
I confess I relate to Daiyu the most -- seeing the simulation, resenting it, writing "poems" (twitter threads, blog posts, notes) that nobody reads and occasionally nuking them.
But the garden is fake, the ending isn't good, and there seems like only a few archetypes of people who can survive the garden. If I already know the garden is fake, why am I still playing it like Daiyu instead of Baochai?
I care about money. I care about status. I want my work to land in the real world, not just as pretty text in a private notebook.
1. Public Baochai
Money/status are "Confucian duties." I treat them the way Baochai treats the Jia clan finances: calculate moves, build alliances, protect the balance sheet.
Practically, it means putting in fixed hours on high‑leverage work, shipping things that compound, talking to people who can move me up, stacking skills that can make money.
2. Private Daiyu
Sensitivity and truth seeking are still needed. I keep the poems, the blackpill thoughts, the late‑night drafts.
However, I must remind myself to stop treating them as the point. I write them, file them, maybe burn them, but it cannot be my core identity when I am yet to be financially rewarded by audiences to such poetry or profound discoveries.
Most people around me won't see the simulation the same way, and its not right to make everyone choose how the simulation was seen.
I look up to Baochai as a rationalist trying to play her best card with the hand she was dealt. She doesn't vent, is observant, pleasant, and acts as part of the difficulty setting. It has been a long time I've operated like this, and so far it has went mostly unrewarded.
One must feel how repressive it is to be a rationalist in a world that is not rational, but another moral in the story is to detach from the cause and effect of the simulation and just "keep playing the game".
Detachment
This oddly brings me back to a song I've written 5 years ago (2021). Detachment is easy to declare, but hard to practice.
If you must choose the material world, then the win condition is money and status, not being understood by others.
Baochai doesn't get a fairy‑tale ending, but she is the one who survives the collapse and keeps the family afloat longer than anyone.
There will be days where it all feels hollow, where people who are asleep in the simulation will still win in ways that look unfair, where the garden clearly rots and you still care about building things, stacking capital, and testing yourself in the material game.
Footnotes
-
Honestly, none of these traits are difficult and unique individually, nor are they unreasonable things to be expecting from a person. It is very common for any man to have all of these cumulative traits. But when it comes to a modern woman, it is indeed very rare for them to have all of these traits combined. ↩