NelworksNelworks

Why Don't We / Season 1 / EP05

The Fire We Refused to Hold (Why Don't We Have Better Nuclear Power?)

Shez

Look at this. They promised us a sci-fi utopia. Infinite, clean power.

Shez

Instead, I'm paying $0.30 a kilowatt-hour and the grid crashes when it gets too hot.

Shez

What happened? Did the physics turn out to be fake?

Kurumi

The physics worked perfectly. We split the atom and released the energy of a star from **Nuclear Fission**.

Kurumi

The engineering didn't fail. **We** failed. We got scared of the fire, so we decided to burn dirt instead.

Shez

Scared? You mean... the bombs?

Kurumi

The bomb started the fear. But the **Regulatory Ratchet** sealed the coffin.

Kurumi

In any other industry, when a plane crashes, we fix the part and keep flying. In nuclear, when a reactor crashes anywhere on Earth, we rewrite the rulebook for *everyone*.

Kurumi

Chernobyl and Fukushima leaked more **Panic** than **radiation**.

Shez

But... shouldn't we be safe? Better safe than sorry?

Kurumi

There is 'safe', and then there is **ALARA**.

Shez

Alara?

Kurumi

It means that if a safety improvement *can* be made, it *must* be made, almost regardless of cost.

Kurumi

Imagine if the government said: 'Car crashes happen. So, every car must now be made of solid tank armor. It must have 50 airbags. It must survive a meteor strike'.

Kurumi

How much do you think that car is gonna cost?

Shez

That car would cost $10 million.

Kurumi

And nobody would buy it. They would walk. Or ride a dangerous bicycle. That is what happened to nuclear.

Kurumi

We made the plants so 'safe' that they became impossible to build. We added so much concrete, so much redundant paperwork, that the construction time went from 4 years to 14 years.

Shez

So the price skyrocketed?

Kurumi

It's called **Negative Learning**. In solar, the more panels you build, the cheaper they get. In nuclear, the more we built (post-1980), the more expensive they got.

Kurumi

Eventually, because we stopped building them, we forgot *how* to build them. The welders retired. The supply chains died.

Shez

Okay, so it's expensive because of fear. But... the waste! The green goo! It lasts 10,000 years! We'll grow a third arm!

Kurumi

Ah. The 'Green Goo' myth. The Simpsons has done more damage to energy policy than the coal lobby.

Kurumi

Look at this. What do you see?

Shez

It looks like... a parking lot for silos? A storage unit?

Kurumi

This is the Maine Yankee nuclear plant's waste storage. This is **20 years** of spent fuel.

Shez

That's it? That tiny square? For 20 years?

Kurumi

That plant generated **119 billion kilowatt-hours**. It powered 500,000 homes for 20 years.

Kurumi

And all the 'deadly waste' left over fits in a space smaller than a tennis court.

Shez

But... isn't it leaking? Glowing?

Kurumi

It's solid ceramic pellets. Inside zirconium rods. Inside steel. Inside concrete.

Kurumi

It's not a liquid. It doesn't flow. You could hug one of those casks and you'd get less radiation than a flight to London.

Kurumi

Now, let's look at the alternative. If that power had come from **Coal**.

Kurumi

A coal plant produces this much toxic ash *every day*. It's full of arsenic, mercury, and... ironically, radioactive uranium.

Shez

Coal is radioactive...?

Kurumi

NIMBYs don't tell you about that part.

Kurumi

And it pumps millions of tons of CO2 into the air, where it kills people via asthma and climate change.

Shez

So... we traded a tiny pile of scary rocks for a planet-sized cloud of poison gas?

Kurumi

We are just choosing the danger we understood (smoke) over the danger we feared (radiation).

Shez

Why didn't we just bury it?

Kurumi

Actually, it's fine where it is. Those casks can safely sit there for a hundred years or more. Deep burial is just one option — like Yucca Mountain in the US — but it's not the only way.

Kurumi

Most people don't know: that 'waste' still contains about 95% of its original energy. It's called 'waste' only because we don't know how to make it work with existing reactors and haven't recycled it.

Kurumi

Now, American companies like TerraPower and Oklo are trying to build reactors that can run on this used fuel. Countries like France are already turning yesterday's 'waste' into tomorrow's clean energy.

Shez

So what did we lose? If we had kept building? If we hadn't let the fear win?

Kurumi

We would have decarbonized the grid by 1990.

Kurumi

France did it. They built 56 reactors in 15 years. Their grid is green. Their electricity is cheap. We could have had that.

Kurumi

We could have had a world where energy was cheap and clean. We could have had a world where we didn't have to choose between the two.

Kurumi

Now? We are still wasting trillions on IPCC science, destroying the West's industrial base, and letting climate activists a reason to destroy the economy and accepting culture wars as a substitute for solving the problem.

Shez

We had the future in our hands, and we dropped it because we watched a scary movies like Hulk and Godzilla

Kurumi

We dropped it because we demanded perfection.

Kurumi

Now, we are trying again. **SMRs** (Small Modular Reactors). Factory-built. Cheaper. Safer.

Shez

Will it work this time?

Kurumi

Only if we learn to fear the lack of energy more than we fear the source of it.

Shez

Can you show me more on how nuclear power and engineering works? All of it.

Kurumi

I may do it in the future!