NelworksNelworks

Why Don't We / Season 2 / EP05

The Most Profitable Scam in History (Why Don't We Have Better Academic Publishing?)

Shez

I did it. I quit the corporate rat race. No more middle managers. No more optimizing ad clicks.

Shez

Now I work for **Science**. I work for the Truth. I'm going to publish this paper so the whole world can benefit from my discovery.

Shez

Submit. And now, we share knowledge with humanity.

Shez

*'Shez, I tried to read your paper, but a website is asking me for $39.95 to rent the PDF for 24 hours. Is this a virus?'*

Shez

What? No, Mom, it's science. It should be free.

Shez

'ACCESS DENIED. Purchase Article: 39.95. Subscribe to Journal:4,000/year.'

Shez

Thirty-nine dollars? I don't get any of that! I did the work! The NIH funded the grant! Why is there a toll booth on my research?

Kurumi

Because you didn't join a monastery, Shez. You joined a **Plantation**.

Shez

Kurumi! This isn't corporate greed. This is academia! We care about knowledge!

Kurumi

The publishers care about margins. Do you know the profit margin of **Elsevier**?

Shez

I don't know... 10%?

Kurumi

It's around **40%**. That is higher than Apple. Higher than Google. Higher than almost any bank.

Shez

How? How is a boring PDF company more profitable than Google?

Kurumi

Because Google has to pay its engineers. Apple has to buy aluminum.

Kurumi

They get the raw material for free. They get the quality control for free. Then they sell the finished product back to the very universities that created it for millions of dollars a year.

Kurumi

It is the perfect business model. It is infinite leverage.

Shez

But... that's theft! Why do we let them? I'll just put my paper on my website! Or arXiv! Free for everyone!

Kurumi

If you do that, you will never get **Tenure**.

Shez

What?

Kurumi

They don't read papers, Shez. They don't have time. They weigh them.

Kurumi

They look at the **Impact Factor** of the journal name. *Nature*. *Cell*. *Science*. These are luxury brands. Publishing on a blog is like drawing a logo on a napkin. It counts for nothing.

Shez

So it's a prestige trap? I have to publish in the expensive journal to get a job?

Kurumi

It's **Signaling**. Just like the college degree. The journal brand is the signal that you are 'serious'.

Shez

But the Journals provide value! They organize the Peer Review! They make sure the science is good!

Kurumi

The 'Journal' is just an email server that pesters overworked grad students to do free labor.

Kurumi

You think Peer Review is an expensive service done by a bunch of sage. It's usually done by a bunch of unpaid grad students.

Kurumi

The publisher adds almost no value. They typeset the PDF. That's it. We solved distribution in 1991 with the internet. Sending a PDF costs 0.0001. They charge40.00.

Shez

Why don't the Universities fight back? Harvard has billions! They should just cancel the subscriptions!

Kurumi

They try. But the Publishers have a weapon: **The Bundle**.

Kurumi

You can't just buy the one good journal. You have to buy a bundle of 2,000 garbage journals to get the one you need. It costs the library millions.

Kurumi

If the library cancels, the scientists revolt because they can't access the research they need to do *their* work. The publisher holds the knowledge hostage. It's a ransom payment.

Shez

So... I quit the corporate world to escape greed...

Kurumi

...and you found a sector that is even more ruthless, because it exploits your passion instead of just your labor.

Shez

Is there any hope? What about Open Access?

Kurumi

Open Access just shifts the cost. Instead of the reader paying, *you* pay the journal $3,000 to publish the article.

Shez

I pay them... to let me work for free?

Kurumi

Its vanity publishing with a better reputation.

Shez

There is one person who fixed it.

Kurumi

Alexandra Elbakyan. The pirate queen of science. She broke the paywall.

Kurumi

It's illegal. It's 'theft'. But it's the only reason science in developing countries functions at all.

Shez

I'm not playing the game. Knowledge belongs to the species, not the shareholders.