NelworksNelworks

Finance / Season 2 / EP10

How Your Credit Score Is Priced

Shez

It's a scam! A total scam!

Kurumi

What is? The Somalian daycares?

Shez

My Car Insurance! They raised my rate by 20%! I didn't even crash!

Shez

They said 'Algorithm Adjustment based on Credit Profile.'

Shez

What does my Credit Score have to do with my driving?!

Shez

Insurance and Credit are boring, bureaucratic scams designed to milk normal people!

Kurumi

Boring?

Kurumi

Shez, Insurance is the oldest Quant Trading market in history.

Kurumi

And Credit? That's just Bond Trading.

Shez

What are you talking about? I'm just a person. I haven't registered for my own CUSIP number and you can't buy any shares of me.

Kurumi

But to an insurance and credit card company, you already a Ticker Symbol they've been trading for years.

Kurumi

And right now, your volatility has been trending up.

Kurumi

When a bank gives you a credit card, they are Buying a Bond. They lend you money (Principal). You pay them coupons (Interest).

Shez

Okay, that makes sense. It's a loan.

Kurumi

But unlike a US Treasury Bond, you might Default. You might run away.

Kurumi

Your 'Credit Score' (650) isn't a grade.

Kurumi

It's a Probability of Default (PD).

Kurumi

Probability. Exposure. Loss.

Shez

...why is my name in the maths. Why is my Xbox in the maths.

Shez

So... the Interest Rate is just the Risk Premium?

Kurumi

Yes. Risk-Based Pricing.

Kurumi

If you are a risky asset (High PD), I need a higher yield (25% APR) to compensate for the chance that you go to zero.

Shez

That sounds cold.

Kurumi

It's efficient. Without this math, banks wouldn't lend to strangers. They'd only lend to friends. The algorithm allows trust to scale globally.

Shez

Okay, fine. Credit is a Bond.

Shez

But Insurance? I pay them to protect me! That's a service!

Kurumi

No. You are buying a Put Option on yourself.

Kurumi

You own the Asset (Car). Value: $30,000.

Kurumi

You are afraid the value will drop to $0 (Crash).

Kurumi

I (The Insurer) sell you a Put Option.

Kurumi

'If value drops to zero, I will buy the wreck for $30,000.'

Shez

And the cost of the option is the Premium?

Kurumi

Exactly. And how do we price an option?

Shez

...Black-Scholes? Volatility?

Kurumi

YOU are the Volatility.

Kurumi

If you drive fast, brake hard, and text while driving... your Implied Volatility (IV) is 100%.

Kurumi

High Volatility = Expensive Option.

Shez

So they raised my rate because they think I'm volatile?

Shez

But I haven't crashed!

Kurumi

You haven't crashed yet. But your Cluster has.

Shez

My cluster?

Kurumi

Statistical Correlation. People with lower credit scores tend to take more risks in life. Including driving.

Kurumi

The model groups you with them. It's Guilt by Association.

Shez

That's profiling! That's unfair! I'm a good driver!

Kurumi

The model doesn't know you. It only knows your Features.

Kurumi

Unless... you give it better data.

Kurumi

Telematics.

Shez

The spy dongle?

Kurumi

The old way was one number a year. Did she crash? No. That was the entire file on you.

Shez

...and now?

Kurumi

Now it is every corner you take too fast, several times a second, for as long as the engine is running.

Shez

so they went from asking once a year to asking constantly while I'm just— driving to work.

Kurumi

And they price you on the answer.

Kurumi

Without this, the Insurer is guessing based on your age and zip code. Low resolution.

Kurumi

With this, they have Tick Data. They can measure your actual volatility in real-time.

Shez

So if I drive like a grandma, the algorithm sees it?

Kurumi

Yes. You move from the 'High Risk' cluster to the 'Low Risk' cluster.

Kurumi

You replace Correlation (Zip Code) with Causation (Actual Driving).

Shez

It's creepy, it's like I'm being stalked.

Kurumi

It makes your insurance Cheaper and Fairer.

Kurumi

True Quants hate 'Pooling.' We hate subsidizing bad drivers.

Kurumi

We want Individualized Pricing.

Shez

So Actuaries... the insurance math guys...

Kurumi

Were the original Quants. They were doing Data Science in the 1700s with mortality tables.

Kurumi

Wall Street just copied their homework and applied it to stocks.

Kurumi

Look at this. 'Probability of Death for Female, Age 25.'

Kurumi

They have calculated the exact odds of your death. To the decimal point.

Shez

Stop. Stop. I haven't made plans for death yet.

Kurumi

It's Reality. Life is a terminal illness with a variable timeframe. Insurance is just a hedge against the timing risk.

Shez

I feel like I'm walking around with a price tag on my head.

Kurumi

You are. We all are.

Kurumi

Every time you swipe a card, you are shorting a bond.

Kurumi

Every time you drive, you are exercising an option.

Kurumi

You are a Proprietary Trader of your own life.

Shez

So if I want to lower my premium...

Kurumi

Lower your Volatility.

Kurumi

Improve your Credit Score (Lower Default Risk). Drive smoothly (Lower Physical Risk).

Shez

I need a better Sharpe Ratio for my existence.

Kurumi

Quant isn't just about stocks. It's about quantifying the uncertainty of the human condition.

Shez

Wait... if I'm an asset class, someone could be doing insider trading on me?

Kurumi

Yes. I could break your fingers and legs on purpose then file an insurance claim. That is insurance fraud.

Shez

DON'T!