NelworksNelworks

Military / Season 1 / EP02

The Surplus Trap

Shez

This is so sad. So deeply, historically tragic.

Shez

Before we settled down and became peaceful farmers, humanity was just a bunch of savage hunter-gatherers murdering each other in the woods.

Shez

Agriculture brought us peace, art, and civilization... but the barbarians just couldn't let us be happy!

Kurumi

You have the causality completely backward. Agriculture didn't invent peace. Agriculture invented war.

Shez

Wrong! War is just bad people doing bad things! Hunters are wild! Farmers are educated and civilized!

Shez

Why would planting wheat cause a war?!

Kurumi

Because you think of war as an emotional event. A clash of good and evil.

Kurumi

War is not an emotion. War is a heavily funded, logistical startup company. And startup companies require a massive Return on Investment (ROI).

Kurumi

Hunters lived in a state of immediate consumption. You catch a deer, you eat the deer. You cannot carry a month's worth of meat on your back. They had zero Surplus.

Shez

Okay. What if I’m a greedy warlord? What if I want to conquer them and steal all their stuff?! Give me your stuff, twerp!

Shez

Hey! Come back here and fight me! I'm oppressing you!

Kurumi

He doesn't have to fight you. He has infinite mobility and zero assets.

Kurumi

Why would he risk getting stabbed to defend a patch of dirt he was going to leave tomorrow anyway?

Kurumi

As a "Warlord"... what exactly are you stealing? Half a basket of berries?

Kurumi

If you attack him, he will just shoot a poisoned arrow into your neck. You risk your life for absolutely zero economic payload.

Kurumi

But around 10,000 BC, someone planted a seed. The Agricultural Revolution happened.

Shez

Ah! Honest, peaceful labor! We are tying ourselves to the land. We are building a community!

Kurumi

You didn't just tie yourself to the land. You invented the ultimate target. You invented the Surplus.

Kurumi

For the first time in planetary history, a single group of humans has cached millions of calories in one highly centralized, static location.

Shez

It’s beautiful! We won't starve this winter! We have a surplus! Having enough is the foundation of peace!

Kurumi

No. In a universe governed by thermodynamics, a massive concentration of unsecured energy is a mathematical provocation.

Kurumi

To a nomad, you don't have a farm. You have an unecrypted Loot Box.

Kurumi

The math changes. Why should they spend a year hunting in winter, when they can just steal three years' worth of food in an afternoon?

Shez

Ahhh! I’ll just do what the hunter did! I’ll run away!

Shez

They can have the dirt! I’m leaving!

Shez

What?! Why am I chained to the food?!

Kurumi

Run? If a hunter runs away, he hunts somewhere else. If a farmer runs away from the harvest... she starves to death in the winter.

Kurumi

The invention of the Surplus destroyed your mobility.

Kurumi

You cannot run. You must stand your ground. You must defend your wealth.

Shez

But I’m a peaceful farmer! I spend my days pulling weeds, not lifting weights! I can't win against Big People.

Kurumi

Exactly. The Raiders are professionals in violence. You are a professional in agriculture. You will lose.

Kurumi

You need to hire your own Brutes. And you are going to pay them using the very Surplus they are hired to protect.

Shez

Yes! Walls! Guards! Protection!

Shez

We won! The peaceful farmers survived!

Shez

Hey! What are you doing?! That’s my grain!

Shez

Protection is not free, citizen. We are taxing you for our protection.

Kurumi

Congratulations. You just invented the State.

Kurumi

You traded a portion of your caloric surplus to fund a permanent, professional class of violent men. The Army.

Kurumi

The raiders steal your grain by force. The guards take your grain as a "tax." To the grain, the math is exactly the same.

Shez

So... civilization is just an extortion racket?

Kurumi

War is the industrialization of robbery.

Kurumi

Before agriculture, violence was a bar fight. A dispute over an insult or a single deer.

Kurumi

But to march ten thousand men across a continent, feed them, equip them, and siege a city for a year?

Kurumi

That requires accounting. It requires logistics. It requires Profit. It's a business model.

Kurumi

You cannot have a professional war without a massive economic infrastructure to fund it.

Shez

He’s an idiot.

Shez

He loaded his chest with treasures and didn't install a dragon to guard it. Someone is gonna loot it.

Kurumi

The moment we stopped running and started hoarding, we signed the contract for perpetual warfare.