NelworksNelworks

Military / Season 1 / EP03

The Leviathan

Shez

That’s it. No more social contracts. We are going back to the old ways.

Kurumi

Someone scammed you out of your legendary loot in your MMO again?

Shez

He stole my +10 Flaming Sword of Righteousness! He tricked me in a trade window!

Shez

I have his IP address! I know where he lives! I am going to drive there and break his keyboard! It is my moral right to punish him!

Kurumi

Your "moral right" to punish him is exactly what destroys civilizations, Shez.

Shez

Why?! If I call the game mods, they’ll just ban him for three days. If I call the police, they’ll laugh at me!

Shez

If someone hurts me, why shouldn't I be allowed to hurt them back? Karma is a bitch.

Kurumi

Karma is a theory. Until you realize human beings are incapable of doing math.

Kurumi

This man stole your property. Under the laws of personal justice, you have the right to retaliate. Go ahead. Balance the equation.

Shez

Take that, twerp! The equation is balanced!

Shez

I got my sword back, he learned his lesson, and the universe is at peace.

Kurumi

The universe is at peace according to your math. But justice is entirely subjective.

Shez

You hit my little brother! He took your stupid toy, and you gave him a concussion! That’s disproportionate!

Shez

I will avenge you!

Shez

Ow! Hey! I was just getting my stuff back!

Kurumi

This is the fatal flaw of decentralized violence: Asymmetric Assessment of Debt.

Kurumi

You think your club strike was a 1:1 repayment for the theft. The brother thinks your strike was an unprovoked escalation.

Kurumi

No one ever believes the punishment they receive is fair. Therefore, every act of "justice" is a new unprovoked crime that demands retaliation.

Shez

Unprovoked crime?! I’ll show him unprovoked! GUILDMATES, ASSEMBLE!

Shez

Come forth, my army of simps! We are going to settle the score!

Kurumi

And here we have the inevitable result of personal justice. The Blood Feud.

Kurumi

If individuals have the right to execute violence, violence never stops.

Kurumi

Every punch thrown to "settle the score" simply creates a new score to settle for the other guy's cousin.

Shez

But... wait! Who’s winning? When does it end?

Kurumi

It doesn't.

Kurumi

It is a perpetual motion machine fueled by human pride. It will burn down the entire world over a single stolen sword.

Shez

Make them stop! Tell them they’re even!

Kurumi

They won't listen to me. I don't have a bigger club than them.

Kurumi

In 1651, a man named Thomas Hobbes wrote a book about this exact nightmare. He called the natural state of man a "war of all against all."

Kurumi

To stop the infinite feedback loop of revenge, humanity had to invent a monster.

Kurumi

Enter the State.

Kurumi

Max Weber defined the State as the entity that holds a Monopoly on the Legitimate Use of Physical Force.

Shez

ALL VIOLENCE IS NOW ILLEGAL. ONLY I MAY STRIKE.

Shez

Neither of you are allowed to execute justice anymore. You surrender your right to violence to ME.

Shez

But he stole my sword! He started it! I am the victim! Let me at him!

Shez

YOU ARE IRRELEVANT. THE CRIME IS NO LONGER AGAINST YOU. IT IS AGAINST THE PEACE.

Kurumi

The Leviathan doesn't punish the thief because it feels bad for you. It punishes the thief because the thief broke the Leviathan's rules.

Shez

PENALTY APPLIED. DEBT TO SOCIETY SETTLED.

Shez

Hey! You can't do that! I'll smash you!

Kurumi

You fool. How dare you stand up against a monopoly?

Shez

OBSTRUCTION NOTED. PENALTY APPLIED.

Kurumi

The State is so powerful that retaliation is mathematically impossible. You cannot feud with the Leviathan. It has all the guns.

Kurumi

And because the Thief's family knows they can't fight the State... the feedback loop of violence is instantly broken. The blood feud ends today.

Shez

It took away my agency. It didn't even ask how I felt. It just treated us both like numbers.

Kurumi

That is the price of civilization.

Kurumi

We trade our emotional satisfaction, our personal vengeance, and our right to swing the bat... so we dont get murdered by our neighbors.

Shez

So... if I drove to that scammer's house and smashed his keyboard...

Kurumi

The State would not care that he stole your digital sword. The State would see an unauthorized use of physical violence and punish you.

Shez

I hate the math of peace. It’s so bureaucratic. I'll report him to the mods.