NelworksNelworks

Military / Season 5 / EP08

Human Shields (Moral Race to the Bottom)

Shez

Oh, I am a strategic god! The devs didn't even see this coming!

Shez

Step one: Hack the enemy support unit! Step two: Make him march directly into his own team's minefield!

Shez

Boom! Two threats eliminated for the price of zero Action Points! I didn't even scratch my own armor!

Shez

Then I figured the next exploit! The enemy AI is programmed to avoid friendly fire!

Shez

Look at this! If I stand behind their civilians, the 'Good Guys' can't shoot me!

Shez

I’m invincible! I have literally hacked the rules of engagement!

Kurumi

"Hacked the rules of engagement?"

Kurumi

You didn't find a brilliant mechanical exploit. You just reinvented the most pathetic, desperate tactic in the history of human conflict.

Shez

Hey! If it works, it works! Why should I fight their tank head-on when I can just use their own allies against them? Asymmetric warfare!

Kurumi

Not this again... Dirty tricks is a one-way ticket to absolute annihilation.

Kurumi

By using a human shield, you are initiating a "Moral Race to the Bottom."

Kurumi

This line is called The Principle of Distinction. It is the single most important rule keeping war from turning into an apocalypse.

Kurumi

For the last century, professional militaries have programmed a specific moral algorithm into their soldiers.

Kurumi

"You only shoot the people holding guns. You never shoot the people without guns."

Shez

Right! Which is why this is brilliant!

Shez

If their algorithm says "Do not shoot civilians," and I wear a civilian like a bulletproof vest, their algorithm crashes! They are paralyzed!

Shez

Haha! Checkmate! Your morality is your weakness!

Kurumi

But look closer, Shez. Look at what you are actually doing to this man's psychology.

Shez

Maintain Morality -> Lose the War -> Your Nation is Destroyed.

Shez

Abandon Morality -> Shoot the Hostage -> Win the War.

Kurumi

You are forcing him into an impossible, binary Game Theory choice.

Kurumi

What do you think a military commander will do when faced with the absolute destruction of their own nation?

Kurumi

Do you think they will just politely accept defeat because you found a loophole in the Geneva Convention?

Shez

I... I mean, they're the Good Guys, right? They have to follow the rules!

Kurumi

No. If you make playing by the rules synonymous with dying... then the enemy will simply stop playing by the rules.

Kurumi

When precision weapons become a liability, they switch to indiscriminate weapons.

Shez

Wait! Stop! That’s an AoE weapon! You’ll hit the civilian! You’re breaking the rules!

Kurumi

You broke the rules first, Shez. You erased the line between combatant and civilian.

Kurumi

Since you proved that distinguishing between the two will only get his men killed, he has mathematically calculated that everyone in your grid square is now a combatant.

Kurumi

The "Good Guy" is dead. You killed him the moment you hid behind an innocent.

Shez

But... that makes them monsters! They killed their own hostage!

Kurumi

Yes. They became monsters. But it was you who made them that way. Their moral restraints are gone forever.

Kurumi

If you force them to murder their own civilians just to get to you...

Kurumi

What do you think they are going to do to you when you finally run out of bullets and try to surrender?

Shez

They... they wouldn't take prisoners.

Kurumi

Exactly. You destroyed the social contract.

Kurumi

By using human shields, you told the enemy, "I have no honor, no rules, and I will exploit your mercy to kill you."

Kurumi

Therefore, the enemy will show you no mercy.

Kurumi

They will not accept your white flag. They will burn your trenches and execute your survivors.

Kurumi

The tactic you thought made you "invincible" is actually a suicide pact.

Kurumi

You proved you were a virus that couldn't be negotiated with.

Kurumi

In asymmetrical warfare, a superior force will eventually get tired of being blackmailed.

Kurumi

They will calculate the "acceptable civilian casualty rate," load the heavy artillery, and flatten the entire city block.

Shez

I was just coward. I sacrificed my own mobility and honor just to delay the inevitable...

Kurumi

Now you understand why taking Hostages is permabanned?