NelworksNelworks

Finance / Season 1 / EP02

How Insurance Actually Works

Shez

I’ve never crashed, never been sick, never had a break-in…

Shez

Why am I paying thousands every year?!

Kurumi

Congratulations.

Kurumi

You just discovered the second greatest magic trick after banking.

Shez

So insurance is another scam?!

Kurumi

Not a scam. A bet.

Kurumi

And the house always wins — by design.

Kurumi

Insurance only works if most customers lose money.

Kurumi

95 people lose money. Their premiums pay for the 5 unlucky ones… plus the company’s profit.

Shez

So I’m paying for everyone else’s problems?!

Kurumi

Exactly. That’s called risk pooling.

Kurumi

Without losers, there’s no money to pay the winners.

Kurumi

...well, if you really think about it, it’s a bad game to be winning anyway.

Kurumi

If you have to be claiming, it must mean there’s something wrong with your life.

Kurumi

And I wouldn’t want anything bad to happen to you.

Shez

B-But someone is still losing money so they stay rich?

Kurumi

If it was so easy, everyone would try to get into the insurance business.

Kurumi

The truth is insurance is a game that can only be played by those with enough capital.

Kurumi

Also, a bad prediction or luck wipes you out.

Shez

That’s true… we can’t predict misfortune. Then how do insurances avoid losing big?

Kurumi

With enough customers and data they will know the exact probability you’ll claim.

Kurumi

Car crash? 6% per year. House fire? 0.03%. They price it so they always win on average.

Kurumi

The perfect customer pays for 40 years and dies the day after the policy ends.

Shez

That doesn’t sound too bad?

Shez

Let me guess, there must be a catch of how they still got me to overpay them for a game they’re already winning, right?

Kurumi

You are sharp.

Kurumi

Mathematically and financially, insurance must be a negative-EV play for consumers.

Kurumi

The only reason you buy it is to avoid letting unlucky events derail you from your usual lifestyle.

Kurumi

Returns compound, so does risk. You buy insurance to stop risk from exploding.

Kurumi

This means it is really foolish to buy insurance for things you can afford to lose.

Kurumi

Phone insurance? Extended warranty? Travel insurance for $50 flights?

Kurumi

Pure profit for them.

Shez

I’ve been scammed for years…

Kurumi

Insurance isn’t evil. It’s a tool. Use it wrong → you’re the product.

Shez

From now on I only insure things that can bankrupt me!

Shez

But my insurance is really expensive…

Kurumi

No choice, you gotta cut those you can.

Kurumi

But certain insurances are really problematic… the law mandates them.

Kurumi

Car insurance and social security, for example…

Shez

H-Hey, doesn’t that mean we are getting screwed again!

Kurumi

Of course~ That’s why we will be talking about Social Security next time~