NelworksNelworks

Finance / Season 1 / EP05

How Brokers Make Money

Shez

CFD / Forex B-Book Broker (2010–2016)

Shez

I get to bet 500 for every1?! I’m going to be rich!

Kurumi

And here’s how this trader is about to make the biggest mistake of her life.

Shez

When a broker operates as the direct counterparty (B-Book), your trade becomes their inventory.

Shez

When you close your losing position, your entire loss amount goes directly to the broker's balance sheet, increasing their revenue.

Shez

plus the spread (the guaranteed profit)

Shez

When you win a trade, the broker is now in a losing position — the potential cost of paying out your profits.

Shez

To prevent this loss from growing, they must Hedge the position.

Shez

2X capital tied up… just to make a spread?!

Shez

Winning clients cost double the capital and yield only the spread.

Shez

A losing client costs less capital and yields more profit (spread + loss).

Shez

There is a conflict of interest between service and customer.

Shez

W-Why is the platform freezing when I'm winning?!

Kurumi

Because the broker’s business model is: the majority of clients must lose so the winners don’t bankrupt them with hedging costs.

Shez

W-Where the hell did you come from?!

Shez

Also my portfolio is confidential so get out of here…

Shez

Four ninety-five a trade. That's a coffee. That's nothing.

Shez

Okay. One more.

Shez

...okay maybe two more.

Shez

Yet, certain customers still don't make money

Shez

I beat the market, but I still lost money?!

Kurumi

Every notification was a dinner invitation… for the broker.

Shez

Where did you come from again?!

Kurumi

Brokers this time get paid the more volume you trade

Kurumi

Of course they give you useless lines that look smart enough to make you act.

Kurumi

You really think if those indicators actually worked, the broker would just hand them to the public for $4.95?

Shez

B-But I worked really hard on it...

Kurumi

Even if they worked, someone smarter on the other side of the world already took the trade before your click registered.

Shez

Commission-Free + PFOF Era (2020–2025)

Shez

Finally, I can stop paying for commissions~

Shez

Now I can trade all day I want~

Shez

Where and how did you sneak in this time?!

Kurumi

PFOF is the revenue stream that allows many retail brokers to offer "zero-commission" trading. It creates a three-way loop

Kurumi

When you place a market order (Buy 100 shares of XYZ), your broker does not send it directly to an exchange (like NYSE or NASDAQ).

Kurumi

Instead, the broker sells the right to execute that order to a wholesale Market Maker (MM), such as Citadel Securities or Virtu Financial.

Kurumi

The MM intercepts your order and executes it using their own inventory

Kurumi

The MM instantly profits from the Bid-Ask Spread

Kurumi

The MM rebates a fraction of their spread profit back to your retail broker as the PFOF.

Kurumi

This payment is the broker's revenue source that subsidizes your "free" trades.

Shez

They made $1.8 billion… from ‘free’ trades?!

Kurumi

You will never see your individual cost.

Shez

It’s hidden in the price itself.

Shez

S-So even ‘free’ trading isn’t free?!

Shez

I'm still paying for commissions, but to someone I don't know?!

Shez

Is there ANY broker that doesn’t screw me?!

Kurumi

Some still exist. They don’t sell your flow or gamify your addiction.

Shez

It feels… empty.

Kurumi

As it should be.

Kurumi

The more you trade, the more someone else eats — no matter who your broker is.

Kurumi

YOU are the liquidity 'consumer' getting charged for your impulse.

Shez

So the ultimate broker hack is…

Shez

Don’t trade too much. Buy and hold high quality companies.

Kurumi

Don’t trade too much. Buy and hold high quality companies.

Kurumi

Congratulations. You are now outperforming 99% of the people still refreshing their portfolios.