NelworksNelworks

Finance / Season 1 / EP08

How Falling Rates Broke Housing

Tweet coming soon
Shez

20 years of zero spending to buy where I live...

Shez

I just want to own a wall that's mine…

Shez

I want to go back to the time when property was still affordable…

Kurumi

Seems like we get the chance to go back to the past.

Shez

W-Where did you come from? Woaaa—

Shez

Year 1979

Shez

Wait… I could buy this with just two years of my salary!

Shez

This hurts… but at least it'll be mine forever if I keep paying.

Shez

Year: 1980-1983

Shez

Good news! We can refinance your mortgage at 10% and hand you $42,000—tax-free!

Shez

Wait what? I get free money, AND a lower interest rate?!

Kurumi

The catch is you will have a new 30 year old loan to replace the old loan you've paid for the last 3 years.

Shez

T-This is fine, right? Money now better than money later.

Kurumi

Yeah, so far. And if you KNOW interest rates are going LOWER, you should TOTALLY use that cash to buy more houses. NFA.

Shez

In 1980, houses are still cheap...

Kurumi

For now. Then it got expensive because everyone who wants one gets one.

Shez

But how?

Kurumi

If a house were a consumer good, lower interest rates would mean a cheaper house.

Kurumi

But when a house is bidded like an investment vehicle, you don't look at the final price. You look at the monthly payment you can afford now.

Kurumi

That is how lowering interest rates directly raise house prices.

Shez

The appraiser didn't go inside. He stood on the lawn and wrote a number.

Shez

My net worth increased, but I still owe what I signed for!

Kurumi

So sign for more. Clear the old loan with the new one and keep what's left over.

Shez

Now I raised $42K cash. I still live here. I didn't have to sell anything!

Kurumi

You borrowed against a price rise nobody worked for. Now spend that cash to "stimulate" the economy or "hoard more land claims against the future"

Shez

1987 · 9%

Shez

This is three months of our wages. We were hoping it'd be just enough for the deposit—

Shez

I'm getting both units. Cash, today.

Shez

And anything else you've got on this street.

Shez

Interest rates lowered again. We can rewrite your loan and hand you the difference—

Shez

How much this time?

Shez

1994 · 7%

Shez

We've saved seven years. We only want the one unit, the small one at the back—

Shez

I'll take the building.

Shez

Keep the model. I'll want the next one too.

Shez

Another interest rates cut came through. Against the twelve units, you could pull—

Shez

Whatever the number, wire me the cash and I will restart the mortgage all over again.

Shez

1998 · 5.5%

Shez

We brought all of it this time. Every—

Shez

I'll buy the strip, the flats above it, and get me a manager to rent them all out!

Shez

Do they ever come back?

Shez

Rates have fallen again. On the whole portfolio this time—

Shez

Don't tell me the number. Just tell me what it buys.

Shez

2005 · 3.8%

Shez

We aren't asking for much any more. One of the small ones, at the back—

Shez

I will take your entire stock!

Shez

My payment went down. Signing it again made my short term debt expense cheaper!

Shez

I didn't add a room. I didn't fix a roof. I signed the same house again and it keeps paying me!

Shez

Year: 2005

Shez

Rent is real. The hotel is real. And I have paid off all of my debt installments with the rental income I harvested from my entire city with cash to spare!

Shez

Wait... Why can't anyone else do what I did?

Kurumi

Because YOU were the few people around when rates were 18%, and then watched them fall for 20 years straight!

Kurumi

Every marble countertop, every hotel fountain, every 'passive income' check—

Kurumi

paid for by people who will never be able to buy in.

Kurumi

The kids are locked out forever!

Shez

I… I stole their future?

Shez

It is not my fault! I just refinanced whenever the banks rang my phone.

Kurumi

You took that cash, then use it to bid against those who haven't start as early as you!

Shez

They could have done the same as well anytime they want.

Kurumi

You started at 18%. Now we are at 3%. What happens when interest rates go 0%?

Shez

T-The money glitch is over?

Kurumi

And that will be the most expensive your real estate will ever get valued

Kurumi

That is how we accidentally made raising rates a political suicide.

Kurumi

If any politician raise rates, housing goes down with them.

Kurumi

And when housing goes, it drags the rest of the economy behind it because every homeowners are stuck with mortgages more expensive than their house's resale value.

Kurumi

No one wants to vote for lower house prices.

Shez

So… they just keep printing.

Shez

I borrowed it from the future… from them.

Kurumi

Time to go home.

Shez

I-I want to go back… please…

Shez

Present - 2025

Shez

If we have to do it all over again, maybe we shouldn't have allowed refinancing.

Shez

There is still a way to turn this around. We can build more houses on new lands, even if it lowers the current prices for existing owners...